Baptist World Alliance

Heritage and Identity Commission

Who are the Baptists?

 

Scotland


 Baptist Work in Scotland - a short history

The first Baptist churches appeared in Scotland between 1650 and 1658, as a result of the evangelistic efforts of soldiers and chaplains in Cromwell's army during their occupation of Scotland. Churches were formed in Leith, Edinburgh, Cupar, Perth, Ayr and Aberdeen. In 1653 Baptists in Leith and Edinburgh reprinted the 1644 London Particular Baptist Confession of Faith and declared their allegiance to its doctrine. It can safely be stated that similar views were held by the other Baptist congregations in Scotland. Persecution arose in 1658 instigated by the Government, due to allegations of political disloyalty against the city of Edinburgh. It is possible that individual Baptists may have been involved but this episode provided an excuse to purge the army and all public offices of Baptists. The majority Presbyterian body was all too eager to assist in the removal of Baptists. From 1660 to 1765 there is apparently no trace of Baptists in official records in Scotland, with the exception of the small isolated congregation gathered in his castle at Keiss in Caithness, in the far north of Scotland, in 1750 by Sir William Sinclair, following his conversion while serving in the British Army.

However, it is probable that small home-based groups of Baptists continued to survive in Scotland. One Baptist family from Glasgow emigrated to Virginia, USA, c.1740. John Duncan Sr and his son of the same name were Baptist preachers; John Jr apparently planted Mt Moriah B.C., Amherst County, Virginia, in 1745. The ecclesiology of this cause was very similar to the Scotch Baptist congregation planted in Glasgow, Scotland in 1765, and closely connected to the understanding of Baptist views promulgated by William Mitchell and David Crossley in West Yorkshire and the Rossendale Valley in the north of England in the early eighteenth century. A further confirmation of this link was the adoption of Baptist views by a Burnley man, William Smith, in Glasgow in 1760. On his return to England he founded Haggate Baptist Church on Scotch Baptist lines, but five years before the official emergence of the Scotch Baptist movement in Scotland.

In 1765 the Scotch Baptist movement was founded in Edinburgh. This movement led by Archibald McLean and Robert Carmichael held to the principle of unanimity in doctrine and practices in their churches, together with a strongly literalist approach to biblical interpretation and a plurality of elders as church oversight. This network of congregations grew steadily until 1810, until a controversy over the necessity of elders at the Lord's Table caused division in their ranks. A repeat of this conflict in 1834 caused the dissolution of their network with some of their more conservative congregations joining the newly formed Churches of Christ, associated with the view of Alexander Campbell and the more open-minded causes uniting with Particular Baptist congregations in Scotland.

 Geroge Barclay

 George Barclay
The first 'English' Particular Baptists in Scotland emerged in the 1790s, but it was only in the early nineteenth century under the leader ship of George Barclay in Irvine and Christopher Anderson, Edinburgh, that their witness began to prosper. Their greater evangelistic zeal led to these Baptists becoming the predominant form of Baptist witness in Scotland by the 1820s. A further cluster of churches emerged in 1808-1810, when Robert and James Alexander Haldane adopted Baptist principles and these congregations adopted the pastor-deacons model of church leadership like the 'English' Baptists.

All three networks of churches formed their own home mission agencies and supported the Baptist Missionary Society, led by William Carey and Andrew Fuller. The three home missions in Scotland were united in one body in 1827, a move that led to significant growth in its work. Attempts at forming a Baptist Union were less successful in this era. The first three attempts begun in 1827, 1835 and 1843 failed, however, in 1869 the present Baptist Union of Scotland was formed on evangelical Baptist lines. The previous efforts had suffered from conflicting ideas over ecclesiology and Calvinistic vs. Arminian doctrinal positions. The influence of the 1859 Revival, a focus on theological education and evangelism were amongst the factors that led to the success of the Union.

Concern for theological education amongst Scottish Baptists began with the decision of George Barclay of Irvine to send Peter McFarlane and Dugald Sinclair to Horton Baptist College, Bradford, England, in 1806. In the period between 1806 and 1837 'English' style Baptists sent twenty-two men from Scotland to this college. However, there was growing concern in the 1830s that the majority of these gifted young men were settling in pastorates in England, rather than returning to their native land. John Street Baptist Church, Aberdeen, approached Horton tutor Benjamin Godwin to see if he would consider starting a small college in Scotland. Godwin declined the invitation. By 1837 a Baptist Academical Society was set up in Scotland, with members from all three streams of Baptist witness, in order to address this issue. Little progress was made until the Baptist Union of Scotland took over the provision of ministerial training in 1845. The students were trained under the auspices of Union secretary Francis Johnston in the Baptist Theological Academy for ten years. In 1857 Dr James Paterson, minister of Hope Street Baptist Church, Glasgow, became the tutor until the formation of the present Baptist Union of Scotland in 1869. The present Scottish Baptist College traces its history to back to 1894. It was, though, only after a bitter struggle in the 1870s and 1880s concerning the right method of training people for ministry within the denomination that the present college was formed. In the twentieth century, however, the overwhelming majority of Scottish Baptists valued the work of the college and the necessity of a proper system of ministerial training. The centenary of the college was attained in 1994. In 2001 the college, although retaining its independence, became associated with the University of Paisley and moved from Glasgow to the Paisley campus of the University.

Baptist numbers in Scotland grew until a peak of 23,310 was attained in 1935, but a steady decline was experienced until the 1950s when this trend was reversed by the converts from the Billy Graham mission in 1955. The downward spiral restarted in the 1960s, though a vigorous policy of church-planting in the 1970s and 80s led to modest growth in the latter decade. By contrast the number of churches had nearly doubled in the last century from 93 in 1892 to 176 in 2004, but the average membership figure declined from a peak of 160 per church in 1906 to 86 in 1997. A renewed focus on the priority of mission in the denomination has produced hopeful signs of progress in the twenty-first century.

by Dr Brian Talbot, Scottish Baptist History Archive, Glasgow

Jan 2006


Back to Who are the Baptists

Back to Main Page